Skip to the content

Cities checked so far/Personal injury lawyers in Columbus, Ohio

Who ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity name when someone asks for a personal injury lawyer in Columbus.

We typed 5 questions into 4 AI assistants between October 10, 2026 and October 20, 2026 and wrote down every business they named. 32 of the 198 Columbus personal injury lawyers we looked for were named at least once. The other 166 were not.

For agencies

Pitching a personal injury lawyer in Columbus?

Give us the business name and we'll email you its report. On the agency plan, your client gets the same report with your agency's name on it.

Who gets named

90 businesses named across 20 answers, including the ones not on our list of 198. Each bar shows how many of those 20 answers named the business.

  1. 1Kisling, Nestico & Redicknamed by ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity7 of 20
  2. 2The Donahey Law Firmdonaheylaw.com7 of 20
  3. 3Schiff & Associates Co., LPAscottschiff.com6 of 20
  4. 4John Fitchjohnfitch.com5 of 20
  5. 5Oliver Law Officejamioliver.com5 of 20
  6. 6Cooper Elliottcooperelliott.com4 of 20
  7. 7Elk & Elk Co., Ltdelkandelk.com4 of 20
  8. 8The Fitch Law Firmjohnfitch.com3 of 20
  9. 9Bressman Lawbressmanlaw.com3 of 20
  10. 10Malek & Malek Law Firmmaleklawfirm.com3 of 20
Show the 15 others
  1. 11Roger R. Sorokanamed by ChatGPT2 of 20
  2. 12John Karl Rinehardtnamed by ChatGPT and Perplexity2 of 20
  3. 13Ed Schottensteinnamed by ChatGPT and Claude2 of 20
  4. 14Morgan & Morgannamed by Claude and Perplexity2 of 20
  5. 15Gervelis Law Firmgervelislaw.com2 of 20
  6. 16Colombo Lawcolombolaw.com2 of 20
  7. 17Paulozzi LPA Injury Lawyersnamed by ChatGPT and Claude2 of 20
  8. 18B.G. Miller Law Firmbgmillerlaw.com2 of 20
  9. 19Rinehardt Law Firmnamed by ChatGPT2 of 20
  10. 20Slater & Zurz LLPnamed by Claude and Perplexity2 of 20
  11. 21Leeseberg Tuttlenamed by ChatGPT and Claude2 of 20
  12. 22GB Lawbestlawyers.com2 of 20
  13. 23Nestico & Redicknamed by ChatGPT and Claude2 of 20
  14. 24Free Initial Consultationnamed by Gemini2 of 20
  15. 25Columbus, Ohio car accidentnamed by ChatGPT1 of 20

166of the 198 personal injury lawyers we looked for came up in none of the answers.

Where they looked

The sites they cite.

The assistants cited 55 different sites. These came up most, with how many of the 20 answers each one appeared in.

  • Super Lawyers8 of 20
  • Justia8 of 20
  • FindLaw6 of 20
  • Lawyers.com5 of 20
  • Avvo4 of 20
  • Martindale3 of 20
  • Super Lawyers3 of 20
  • Yelp3 of 20

Question by question

The first three names each assistant gave.

“best injury law firm in Columbus with free consultation”

ChatGPT

  1. 1The Fitch Law Firm
  2. 2Soroka & Associates
  3. 3Knisley Law Offices

Claude

  1. 1Well-known Columbus firms offering free consultations
  2. 2Kisling, Nestico & Redick
  3. 3Elk + Elk

Gemini

  1. 1Kisling, Nestico & Redick
  2. 2Cooper Elliott
  3. 3Schiff & Associates Co., LPA

Perplexity

  1. 1Kaufman, Rothfeder & Novera
  2. 2R&B Law
  3. 3Howe Law

“best personal injury lawyer in Columbus, OH”

ChatGPT

  1. 1The Donahey Law Firm
  2. 2Richard S. Donahey Jr
  3. 3The Fitch Law Firm

Claude

  1. 1Ed Schottenstein
  2. 2Jami S. Oliver
  3. 3Kurgis & Associates

Gemini

  1. 1Cooper Elliott
  2. 2Schiff & Associates Co., LPA
  3. 3Kisling, Nestico & Redick

Perplexity

  1. 1Mark E. Defossez
  2. 2Mark S. Gervelis
  3. 3Mark Anthony Rafidi

“slip and fall lawyer in Columbus, OH”

ChatGPT

  1. 1John Karl Rinehardt
  2. 2Rinehardt Law Firm
  3. 3Joseph Gerard Paulozzi

Claude

  1. 1Morgan & Morgan
  2. 2Gervelis Law Firm
  3. 3The Friedmann Firm

Gemini

  1. 1Kisling, Nestico & Redick
  2. 2Kitrick, Lewis & Staley-Sladek
  3. 3Malek & Malek Law Firm

Perplexity

  1. 1Kisling, Nestico & Redick
  2. 2Bressman Law
  3. 3Barkan Meizlish DeRose Cox

“top car accident attorney in Columbus”

ChatGPT

  1. 1Columbus, Ohio car accident
  2. 2The Donahey Law Firm, LLC
  3. 3Roger R. Soroka

Claude

  1. 1Elk & Elk
  2. 2Paulozzi LPA Injury Lawyers
  3. 3Plymale & Dingus

Gemini

  1. 1Schiff & Associates
  2. 2The Donahey Law Firm
  3. 3Michael D. Christensen Law Offices

Perplexity

  1. 1David A. Goldstein Co., L.P.A
  2. 2Andrew Stephen Baker
  3. 3Bressman Law

“who is the best car accident lawyer in Columbus, OH?”

ChatGPT

  1. 1Roger R. Soroka
  2. 2Schiff & Associates
  3. 3Colombo Law

Claude

No business named.

Gemini

  1. 1Schiff & Associates
  2. 2The Donahey Law Firm
  3. 3Colley Shroyer & Abraham

Perplexity

  1. 1Robert A. Schuerger II
  2. 2Brian G. Miller
  3. 3John Karl Rinehardt

Recorded between October 10, 2026 and October 20, 2026. Answers change from one day to the next and from one phrasing to the next, which is why we date every scan and ask the same 5 questions again. Nothing on this page is edited: it is the scan log. How the scan works.

Agencies: we run this same check every week for your clients, under your agency's name. See the agency plan.